Should I sell my Woodford fund? – fund expert Mark Dampier gives his view

Neil Woodford - keep or trade.jpg

Despite originally having a target of £250 million, Terry Smith ended up raising £823 million for his new Smithson fund. With this huge chunk of cash smashing through Neil Woodford's previous record of £800 million in 2015, now seems like a good time to ask:

Are there better times ahead for Neil Woodford?

Almost twelve months ago, our friendly fund expert Mark Dampier of Hargreaves Lansdown said investors should sit tight in Neil Woodford funds after a run of poor performance.


Is he sticking to this view?

Mark says: "It has been a tough time for Neil Woodford. He has suffered significant redemptions, his style remains out of favour and the UK is one of the most hated markets. I’ve never seen it so unpopular. It would be great if Neil could be left to get on with things, but he has a high profile and will remain in the spotlight.

I would say a few things: the first is that investors shouldn’t be looking at someone when they’ve had a very strong run of performance, but when they’ve had a weaker run. Neil has a 30-year track record. He has had difficult periods before and recovered. He has made mistakes, but his style of ‘value’ investing has been very out of favour.

Also, Neil has two macroeconomic premises driving his stock selection. The first is that there will be a deal on Brexit. The second is that there won’t be a Labour government. His fund is geared to unloved domestic companies, which are very cheap. If someone doesn’t agree, they probably shouldn’t buy his fund - but they probably shouldn’t buy the UK market.

It is also worth adding that investors shouldn’t just be holding Neil’s fund, but a range of different funds. Is it worth holding his fund alongside those of say, Clive Beagles at JO Hambro? These two funds don’t have much cross-over of holdings and tend to perform differently. Clive has been growing the dividend on his fund by around 10% per year. If investors want a more ‘middle’ option, the Artemis Income fund might be a good choice.

If every fund you hold is firing on all cylinders, it could be a reason to worry. It means they are all pointing in the same direction, which may hurt if the market turns.

Investors need to be patient if they are buying an active manager such as Neil. If they can’t take the pressure, perhaps a passive fund might be a better option."


Learn the Tribal Way

What are other people doing? Learn from their experiences.

If you know your shares from your SIPPs but could still use a few tips, you might be an Intrepid Investor. Take a look at our specialised Learning Path for an ISA MOT and some fund ideas.

Intrepid Investors

What's next?

Join the thousands of people who get our weekly musings on money, great products, top tips and a dollop of opinion.

Sign up for Holly's blog

Mark Dampier's original answer, December 2017

Should I sell Woodford Equity Income or wait for it to recover?

Want to know more?

How long do stock markets take to recover.jpg

How long do stock markets take to recover?

We look at the five most recent stock market crashes, the impact they had and how long they took to bounce back again.

How long do stock markets take to recover?

Related Questions

Got a Question?

Sign up for Holly's blog

Stay up to date

Our free weekly blog with Holly's
no-nonsense opinions, tips & food for thought.
If you change your mind, you can unsubscribe at any time.