Cash ISA Guide: Allowances, Easy Access vs Fixed Rate, and Common Mistakes

The basics of Cash ISAs

In a nutshell

Reliable and steady unlike stock markets

No strings - take your money out when you need it

Pay no tax on any interest you earn

Get going online from just £1 a month

What is a Cash ISA?

Cash is the safe bespectacled librarian to the more flamboyant rock star that is shares. A Cash ISA (or Individual Savings Account if you're feeling talkative) is a type of bank account where you can keep your savings in cash - rather than, say, invested in the stock market - and tuck away up to £20,000 in a year. The best bit? Money you put in a Cash ISA is shielded from the taxman, so any interest you earn on your savings is entirely yours to keep!

How do Cash ISAs work?

Cash is King, or so they used to say. There's a lot to be said for boring and safe - you know exactly what you're getting, as unlike with a Stocks & Shares ISA invested in the stock market, your cash is less likely to suddenly freefall in value at any given time. Not 100% outside the realms of possibility - nothing is guaranteed - but you can generally expect a much steadier ride with cash.

With a Cash ISA, you can tuck away up to £20,000 every year and not have to worry about paying tax on any interest you earn! They make for a great emergency fund stash, as you can usually withdraw your cash very quickly if you need to. However, Cash ISAs aren't so great when inflation is high, as its purchasing power is decreasing over time and you could end up with less than the value of what you put in after a few years.

Although it's tempting, cash isn't necessarily always the right answer, particularly if you're saving for a longer-term goal and have more time on your hands. Not sure if a Cash ISA is right for you? Scroll down to delve into the pros and cons to help you decide.

Easy access vs fixed-rate Cash ISAs

When it comes to Cash ISAs, not all options are created equal. Choosing the right type depends on your financial situation, goals, and how soon you might need to access your money. Let's break down the two main varieties to help you decide which one best suits your needs.

There are two main types of Cash ISA: easy access and fixed-rate.

Easy access

An easy access Cash ISA allows you to withdraw money from your account, making it ideal for those who want flexibility. However, some providers have a cap on the number of withdrawals you can make, or reduce the interest on your account if you exceed a certain number of withdrawals in a given period. The interest rates on these ISAs are typically variable, meaning they can fluctuate, and are heavily influenced by the Bank of England's base rate.

Good for you if

You may need to dip into your savings from time to time

You're unsure about locking your money away in a fixed account

You want a backup emergency fund but still want to earn tax-free interest

Fixed-rate

A fixed-rate Cash ISA, on the other hand, locks your money away for a set period (usually 1-5 years, depending on which period suits your needs best) in exchange for a guaranteed interest rate. The trade-off is that early withdrawals may come with penalties, so this option is best for those who don’t need immediate access to their savings.

Good for you if

You don’t need access to your cash for a set period

You want to lock in a guaranteed interest rate

You’re saving towards a medium-to-long-term goal, such as a house deposit

Is a Cash ISA right for me?

Picking between a Cash ISA or a Stocks & Shares ISA, for example, can be a bit of a confusing task. Ultimately, it comes down to how long you're investing for and how much risk you're comfortable with. Check out the pros and cons of Cash ISAs in the table below to work out if they're the right choice for you.

Good if

You want near-100% certainty that your money is safe

You might need your money sooner rather than later

Want a rainy day or emergency fund pot

Bad if

You're saving for the longer-term (>5 years)

You'd rather invest than sit on cash

Inflation is high

Cash ISA: Cash vs stock market

Cash ISAs are popular savings vehicles because they're reliable, they're easy to get your head around, and - for the most part - you get back what you put in. But will siding with good old reliable cash mean you're missing out? Well, according to recent history, it might well do.

The graph below demonstrates the respective growth of stock markets and cash in the period between 2015 and 2025.

Although many of us (understandably) fear the perceived risk that comes with the stock market, this chart helps to put it into perspective. There will be years when you make losses - that's largely unavoidable - however markets tend to rebound fairly quickly and over time your money is statistically likely to grow. Though cash is more predictable than the stock market, inflation - especially when it's higher than interest rates - means that your money is effectively less powerful with every passing day.

Cash ISA: Short-term vs long-term saving

It's this lingering threat of inflation that forces us to consider timing when it comes to Cash ISAs - specifically, how long you're going to be putting your money away for before you need to withdraw it.

Looking at returns over the decade between 2015-2025, you can see that if £10,000 was invested in either the FTSE 100, MSCI World Index or in cash, the MSCI World Index came out on top.

As an aside, it's interesting to observe that over this 10-year period, the FTSE 100 lagged significantly behind the MSCI World Index. This is a welcome reminder about the benefits of diversification (the art of NOT putting all your eggs into one basket)!

However, the main story here is that investing your money - rather than having it sit in a bank account in wads of cash - would've earned you more money in the long run. So while the safety and security that comes with cash is a great failsafe if you think you might need to access your money quickly - for an emergency fund, for example - or for something very important to you, like a deposit on a flat, the stock market tends to perform significantly better over a longer period of time.

That's why it's often helpful to think of cash vs the stock market in terms of timeframes. If you're going to need your money within the next 5 years, then cash - in a Cash ISA, so you don't have to worry about tax - makes a lot of sense. But if you're thinking about financial goals that are further away into the future - such as retirement - then putting your money into the stock market and making money off its long-term growth might be a better idea.

Common Cash ISA mistakes to avoid

1. Leaving money in a low interest ISA account: Many people stick with older Cash ISAs paying dismal rates. Check your rate regularly and consider transferring to an ISA with a more competitive rate if necessary.

2. Not using your ISA allowance: Your annual ISA allowance doesn’t roll over. If you don’t use it by 5 April each year, you lose it.

3. Assuming all Cash ISAs work the same way: Not all easy access Cash ISAs allow you to dip in and out an unlimited number of times, for example, and may have a cap for each tax year. Always read the fine print before opening an account.

4. Failing to transfer ISAs properly: If you want to move your Cash ISA to a provider with a better interest rate, make sure you use the official ISA transfer process. Withdrawing out of the tax-free ISA wrapper and depositing back in manually could result in losing your tax-free benefits. Different providers may also charge exit fees so make sure to check the small print when moving your money around.